|
No Child Left Behind: Middle schools try to meet standards for teachers
By Jodi Wolfe
Staff Writer
Now that the federal government’s No Child Left Behind
Act has been put into practice,
teachers are working to meet the
new standards of being “highly
qualified” set by the federal
government.
School districts throughout
the greater Manchester area are
handling the federal regulations
differently. All teachers are supposed to be highly qualified by
the end of the 2005-06 school
year.
“Highly qualified” means dif-
ferent things for different grade
levels, and school officials
agree that middle school teachers are the most affected by the
new regulations.
In New Hampshire, middle
school teachers can have a
degree in elementary education
and not be certified in their content field or subject, said
Roxanne Wilson, assistant
superintendent of schools for
SAU 24, which includes the
Weare School District.
“All of our teachers, they’ve
been teaching for years with
kindergarten to eighth-grade
degree and never had to have
content endorsement,” she said.
According to No Child Left
Behind regulations, if a teacher
teaches three subjects or more,
the teacher does not need a deep
understanding in each subject; if
a teacher teaches only two subjects, the teacher does need a
deep understanding of the subject.
To be considered highly qualified in a subject means one of
the following: being certified in
the subject, passing the Praxis
II assessment test in the subject,
having 30 college credits in the
subject, or completing a high,
objective, uniform, state standard of evaluation (HOUSSE)
plan portfolio in the subject.
Area teachers are either working on creating plans to be considered highly qualified or finishing their plans. Having a plan
to be be highly qualified in a
subject means that teachers
need to have a date to take the
Praxis II test, have a HOUSSE
plan written, or be enrolled in
college courses in that subject.
For teachers who have been
out of college for 15 years, taking the Praxis II test could be
difficult, said Betsey Cox
Stebbins, principal of the
Armand R. Dupont School in
Allenstown.
“That’s just arbitary at that
point,” said Chip McGee, an
assistant superintendent for the
Bedford School District. “The
true master teacher simply
needs to prove that they have
the experience with the context
that is required.”
The HOUSSE plan involves
working with what the government considers a highly qualified teacher and putting together
a portfolio, which is time-consuming, said Stebbins.
“There’s nothing easy about
it,” she said. “It requires work,
time, and money.”
However, teachers need to be
highly qualified in core academic areas, which doesn’t include
classes such as technical education, said Wilson.
In the Bedford School
District, 89 percent of the teachers – including special education teachers, currently meet the
highly qualified teacher requirements while the rest are working
on plans to be highly qualified,
according to McGee. Amajority
of
Bedford teachers prepared
HOUSSE plans in order to be
qualified under No Child Left
Behind standards, he said. The
state gave the school district a
Sept. 15, 2003, deadline to have
teachers on a plan to be highly
qualified.
“I’ve been very impresesed
with the work our teachers and
instructors have done to be
highly qualified, said McGee.
Of course, there is a difference between high-qualified
and high-quality teachers,
McGee said.
“We’ve got 30-year veterans
who have been teaching math
wonderfully for a number of
years, but don’t have bachelor’s
degrees,” he said.
Special education teachers’
qualifications are based on
developmental levels of their
students, not their age, McGee
said.
“Special education teachers
are really at a tough spot in this
law,” he said. “They have so
much training in special education that they may not have 30
credits in math as well.”
Due to changing class sizes,
small school districts often have
teachers teaching subjects they
are not qualified for under the
federal guidelines.
“We don’t face that same
problem to the degree that some
districts do,” said McGee.
The Bedford School District
has seen some benefits because
of the No Child Left Behind
Act. For example, the district
ran a program called “Calculus
for Cats,” a workshop for math
teachers teaching grades 5
through 8.
“By running this workshop,
not only did they meet the
requirements, but we had this
nice workshop,” McGee said.
In the Weare School District,
the administration began working on new regulations right
after it was aware of the federal
act, said Dr. Christine Tyrie,
superintendent of schools.
In 2003, the administration
set up a system based on the No
Child Left Behind teacher’s tool
kit and then trained the administration to work with the staff to
meet the requirements.
The administration met with
all the teachers and examined
their transcripts to set them on
the right track. Administrators
found that some teachers had 30
credit hours in their subject,
making them highly qualified,
said Wilson.
“There were actually quite a
few teachers that met the
requirements by transcripts,”
she said.
By the end of the 2003-04
school year, all 36 teachers at
Center Woods, Weare’s elementary school, were highly qualified, said Wilson. At Weare
Middle School, six out of 30
teachers are on plans and the
others have met the requirements through transcript
reviews, by passing the Praxis II
test or via certification, she said.
At John Stark Regional High
School, more than 90 percent of
teachers met the regulations.
In SAU 19, which encompasses the Goffstown School
District, the New Boston School
District and the Dunbarton
School District, all the principals sat with their teachers to go
over their plans on an individual
basis, said Dr. Darrell
Lockwood, superintendent of
schools.
Administrators also did background checks on the teachers to
see if they had credits to meet
the regulations, he said.
Several teachers have taken
the Praxis II and passed and others have developed plans and
near completion of those plans,
The majority of the teachers
chose to use HOUSSE plans, he
said.
The administration at SAU 19
also created study groups for
teachers.
In the Allenstown School
District, all teachers need to
have plans to be highly qualified
by Jan. 31. “Many of our teachers don’t have a plan,” said
Stebbins.
Currently there are two out of
13 teachers at the Dupont
School who met the No Child
Left Behind’s standards of
being highly qualified in one
subject and there are no teachers
highly qualified in more than
one subject, said Stebbins.
However, being highly qualified in one subject under the
federal regulations doesn’t necessary solve the problem, so the
administration is recommending
teachers become highly qualified in one than one subject,
said Stebbins. With a small district and ever-changing grade
sizes, Allenstown middle school
teachers often have to take on
subjects they are not highly
qualified in, said Stebbins.
“Or they are highly qualified
to teach something we don’t
need,” she said. “It’s very difficult at the middle school level.”
Kim Carbonneau, a sixth-
grade teacher at the Dupont
School, usually teaches language arts and social studies.
This year, she’s only teaching
language arts because of class
arrangements. She has yet to
determine her plans to meet the
new standards.
“‘No Child Left Behind’ is a
wonderful catch phrase, but
does the policy address what
children need? They need
healthy, sound buildings with a
room for every class,”
Charbonneau said. “They need
programs like art, music, physical education, and language.
They need smaller classes and
dedicated teachers. I’m not sure
that NCLB is impacting children in a way that I hope, at
least, it was intended.”
Peter Letvinchuk, a seventh-grade teacher in Allenstown, is
planning to take the Praxis II in
order to meet the No Child Left
Behind Act’s standards.
Letvinchuk has a bachelor’s
degree in business and has been
teaching for five years.
While he is halfway through
working on a master’s degree in
education at Rivier College,
none of those courses will help
with the No Child Left Behind
regulations, he said.
This year, he is teaching language arts and math, but next
year he will only teach language
arts, so that is the subject he will
take a test on. Unfortunately for
Letvinchuck, there isn’t a Praxis
II test for middle school language arts, only for the high
school level.
While he is certified to teach
kindergarten through grade 8,
he will be qualified to teach
high school, he said.
Letvinchuk said he doesn’t
disagree with the law because
teachers should be accountable
for the subjects they are teaching, but he would like to see
some changes.
“My hope would be that they
change the law to at least be
more specific,” he said. “It’s a
good law, but it almost penalizes the middle school teachers.”
|